I’ve sworn that I will never again buy any of those overpriced DVDs at the local drugstore but I just couldn’t resist getting the HBO movie Grey Gardens last night. The movie is based on the 1975 cult documentary of the same title by the Maysles Brothers, and Grey Gardens is the name of the decayed mansion, where Jackie Onassis’ aunt and cousin, the two Edith Beales (“Big Edie” and “Little Edie”), lived in isolation—and in filth, that is, in very unsanitary and unhygienic conditions. I wasn’t really expecting a lot from the HBO movie, since nothing can replace the documentary, but it turned out to be actually quite good. Jessica Lange and Drew Barrymore looked and acted like the Real McCoys, and the script, in a way, clarifies a few questions that were kind of left open in the documentary (e.g., why Big Edie didn’t want to leave Grey Gardens and why Little Edie chose to stay with her). When I first saw the documentary, I cringed (because of the dirt—you could even almost smell it), laughed (because the two Edies were hilarious and lovable) and cried (because of the tragic undertones). The HBO film will make you feel the same, in a lesser extent though.
Both The Criterion Collection and The Masters of Cinema Series have their respective editions of the Maysles Brothers’ Grey Gardens. HBO’s 2009 Grey Gardens is presently very much available anywhere. Just don’t buy it from my local drugstore.